Hullabaloo in the guava orchard

This is Kiran Desai’s first novel – she won the Booker in 2006 with her second – Inheritance of loss. I really loved that book and I don’t know why it took me so long to buy & read this one, but…there you go.

I wasn’t the least bit disappointed, though it’s very obvious how much Ms. Desai grew in the 8 years that passed between the 2 novels. Where The Inheritance of Loss is complex and follows several stories, Hullabaloo focuses on Sampath Chawla and his search for freedom. In fact, Sampath is nothing but a lazy 20smonething year old who doesn’t want to deal with life, adulthood and responsibilities. In school he’s done badly, he loathes the position his father got him as a clerk in the post office…in fact, he hates everything and everyone around him. All he wants is to be alone, just like an angry teen.

But his likeability – or lack of – doesn’t account for much in this charming little novel. What “makes” it is the secondary characters, the people of Shahkot: Mr. Chawla, with his ambition for his kids, Kulfi, his food obsessed wife (in fact, Kulfi seems like quite the cooking whiz, eternally unsatisfied and unmotivated, like her son – who gets to be the only one to taste her wondrous novelty dishes), the gossiping neighbours, the confused and unprofessional officials and, of course, the drunken monkeys. Ms. Desai is immersed in all this “small town India” – loud, colourful, funny, aromatic, chatty – and the atmosphere is engulfing, almost palpable. Sampath’s unpredictable transformation from angry and frustrated to revered holy man happens pretty much over night (and is, of course, an unintentional sham), but, as Mr. Chawla finally seems to catch a thread of something that could justify the expectations he’s had for his son he only manages to slowly disturb the balance and speed up the downfall.

And about this “downfall” – without giving too much away – a review I read confused me a bit. I understood it one way, and they got something totally different. Now I kinda doubt my own take on things, but if anyone has read it – please, pleasee share what you make of the ending.  😀

Anyways, if you like this kind of “indian” novels – you’ll love this one. But if Ms. Desai’s Booker effort didn’t convince you, then this probably isn’t something you’ll enjoy better. 😉 And that’s it for the advice – this has been post no. 101, and I wanted to point that out because, as the Depeche Mode fan that I am, the number 101 has some sort of significance 😛


~ by ameer on October 10, 2008.

5 Responses to “Hullabaloo in the guava orchard”

  1. Indian novels have always been fascinating. I wish I could buy this one on one of the bookstore here in the Philippines.

  2. Hmm, you could try 😉

  3. I enjoyed reading this book but thought that the book in itself was a bit too short. I wanted some more exploration of the characters because I was just beginning to enjoy the story when it ended abruptly.Even I am wondering what actually happened. Most importantly who or what fell in the pot?

  4. Hi!

    The ending was rather abrupt. With all the event leading up to the climax, pinky and the hungry hop boy, the brigadier and kulfi with her desire for monkey all brought to this one day, this one moment. To my disappointment, Desai ended with a rather peculiar way with the spy falling in the pot. Is he suppose to be representing a monkey? Now with the disappearance of Sampath. I discussed with others, people either said that Sampath became the Guava or he simply departed.


  5. i liked the book but wished it had a better ending.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: